Carmina Shoes Review 2023: Are They Any Good?

Carmina is a renowned Spanish shoemaker known for producing high-quality men’s dress shoes. With roots tracing back to 1866, the company has a long-standing tradition of craftsmanship and expertise in shoemaking. The brand officially became Carmina in 1997, founded by Jose Albaladejo Pujadas and his family. Located in Inca, Mallorca, Carmina operates from the heart of the shoemaking center in Spain.

Carmina Shoes Review

What Makes Carmina Shoes Unique?

Carmina shoes stand out in the market for several reasons. Here are some factors that contribute to their uniqueness:


Carmina offers an impressive range of 27 different lasts, allowing customers to find a fit that suits their foot shape and preferences. The availability of different widths further enhances the customization options, making it easier to achieve a more personalized fit. Whether you prefer a longer or shorter last, a wider or slimmer fit, Carmina provides ample choices to cater to individual needs.

Quality Leathers:

Carmina prides itself on using a wide variety of leathers, offering customers a diverse selection. They source their leathers from reputable tanneries and provide detailed information about the origin and type of leather used. From box calf and suede to exotic skins like lizard and crocodile, Carmina caters to different tastes and preferences.

Carmina Shoes Review


Carmina shoes are known for their excellent construction and attention to detail. The brand employs skilled craftsmen who meticulously stitch the uppers, ensuring neat and precise workmanship. The shoes feature all-leather heels, leather outsoles, and leather insoles. The use of a combination of high-quality materials and sturdy stitching results in durable and well-made footwear.

Sole Options:

Carmina offers a wide range of sole options to suit different needs and preferences. From traditional leather soles to rubber soles and commando soles, customers have the flexibility to choose based on their desired style and practicality. The availability of sole customization enhances the overall appeal and versatility of Carmina shoes.

Carmina Shoes Reviews

Carmina shoes have received positive reviews from customers and shoe enthusiasts alike. The quality of materials, attention to detail in construction, and comfortable fit are often praised. The wide range of lasts and leather options allows customers to find the perfect shoe to suit their style and preferences. While the shoes may require a break-in period due to their initial stiffness, they tend to soften and become more comfortable with wear.

You Can Read:  PUMA MB 01 Queen City: Uniting Urban Fashion With High-Performance Footwear

Overall Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Based on their craftsmanship, material selection, and customization options, Carmina shoes are highly regarded in the market. With their attention to detail and commitment to providing a wide range of sizes and fits, Carmina earns a five-star rating for their overall quality.

Carmina Shoes Review

Pricing Overview

Carmina shoes are positioned in the middle price range for high-quality dress shoes. The majority of their shoes are priced at £329, €395, or $475. The actual price may vary depending on the model, leather type, and any additional customization options chosen. While Carmina does offer occasional sales, their standard pricing offers excellent value for the craftsmanship and materials provided.

Shipping Process

Carmina provides shipping services worldwide, allowing customers to purchase their shoes from anywhere. Shipping times and costs may vary depending on the destination. Customers should refer to Carmina’s official website for specific details and options available for their respective countries.

Customer Service

Carmina’s customer service has received mixed reviews. While the brand’s shoes are highly regarded, some customers have expressed dissatisfaction with the customer service experience. Instances of limited responsiveness or inflexible policies regarding discounts and returns have been reported. It’s recommended to be aware of the brand’s policies and communicate any concerns or issues promptly.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are Carmina shoes true to size?

Carmina shoes generally run true to size, but it’s important to note that the fit can vary depending on the last you choose. Carmina offers a wide range of lasts, each with its own characteristics and fit. It’s recommended to consult Carmina’s sizing guide or reach out to their customer service for guidance on choosing the right size and last for your feet.

How is the comfort level of Carmina shoes?

Carmina shoes are known for their comfort once they are broken in. Some customers have mentioned that the shoes can feel initially stiff, especially with certain leather types or thicker soles. However, with regular wear, the shoes tend to mold to the shape of the foot, providing a comfortable fit. It’s important to allow for a break-in period to let the shoes adapt to your feet.

You Can Read:  Chiko Shoes Review: Is It Worth It 2023?

How is the durability of Carmina shoes?

Carmina shoes are highly regarded for their durability. The brand utilizes high-quality materials and employs traditional construction methods, such as Goodyear welted and Blake stitching, which contribute to the long-lasting nature of the shoes. Customers have reported that Carmina shoes hold up well over time, even with regular use.

Can Carmina shoes be resoled?

Yes, Carmina shoes can be resoled. The Goodyear welted construction of most Carmina shoes allows for easy resoling, extending the lifespan of the footwear. The brand also offers a resoling service for their shoes, ensuring that you can continue to enjoy your Carmina footwear for years to come.

Where can I purchase Carmina shoes?

A: Carmina shoes can be purchased online through the official Carmina website. They have an online store where you can browse their collection and make a purchase. Additionally, Carmina has authorized retailers worldwide, and you can check their website for a list of physical stores that carry their shoes.

Final Thought

Based on customer reviews and feedback, Carmina shoes are highly regarded for their quality craftsmanship, comfortable fit (after the break-in period), and wide range of customization options. The brand’s commitment to using high-quality materials and traditional construction methods has earned them a reputation for producing durable footwear.

While some customers have had mixed experiences with Carmina’s customer service, the overall consensus on the shoes remains positive. With their extensive range of lasts, diverse leather options, and attention to detail, Carmina shoes continue to be a popular choice among men seeking well-crafted and stylish footwear.

About The Author

Scroll to Top